Forty-three-year-old Stanley Caudill of Clayhatchee is charged with rape and sexual abuse.
Police said the victims were 16 and 17 years old when the crimes were committed about a year ago.
Investigators only recently learned about the attacks.
Caudill's bond has been set at $40,000.
|Get the ingredients you need to cook with Rach all week long.|
|Full length exclusive concerts from hot artists.|
|Take a break!
Classic Pacman, Frogger, Asteroids and more.
Sell almost anything locally.