Thirty-three-year-old Jerry Bryant was found guilty in the January 1997 kidnapping and shooting death of another man.
The body of 27-year-old Donald Hollis was found off a dirt road in Florida, but prosecutors said he was abducted and killed in Dothan.
The same jury that convicted Bryant also voted 11-1 for the death penalty.
But the State Supreme Court has ruled those jurors were not properly instructed before they deliberated.
Bryant's conviction will stand but a new jury will have to be picked for re-sentencing and Bryant could get life without parole.
A hearing date has not been set.
Viewers with disabilities can get assistance accessing this station's FCC Public Inspection File by contacting the station with the information listed below. Questions or concerns relating to the accessibility of the FCC's online public file system should be directed to the FCC at 888-225-5322, 888-835-5322 (TTY), or firstname.lastname@example.org.